This is an ever present problem with people tagging something with a label to make an item more attractive to the buyer.
The term “Antique” is a term universally accepted to place an item in an era; this era is 100 years or older.
Likewise with “Vintage” which is 50 years or older.
Victorian is dated between 1837 and 1901.
Plastic Rocking Horses really didn’t start till the 1970’s.
Fiberglass not really till the 1960’s.
Many times on auction sites etc we see horses which are incorrectly labelled as “Vintage” or “Antique”.
So how do we know how old a Rocking Horse actually is?
Well; the chances of an Australian Rocking Horse being “Antique” is fairly slim. Sure there are still Australian Rocking Horses over 100 years old; but these horses can only be a Roebuck which started making rocking horses in Australia in 1880, Bartlett which started making Rocking Horses in 1913 and Lou Peets in 1915.
There are very few turn of the century Roebuck Rocking Horses still in existence; so; if you see an Australian Rocking Horse labelled as “Antique” then you can be 99% sure it is mislabeled. The majority of Rocking horses still surviving are post WWII; this does however make many of them “Vintage” or close to it.
There are many turn of the century English Rocking Horse still available; but not that many in Australia; and those are brought in and owned by collectors.
Also; Plastic Rocking Horses are generally from the 1970’s and Fiberglass from the 1960’s; so if you see a plastic horse dated 1940’s; don’t fall for it.
There are however five particular types of Rocking Horses which are constantly misrepresented on general auction sites; these are often advertised as “very old”, or “Antique” or “Vintage” or “1800’s”. You often see them with descriptions such as “belonged to my great Grandmother” or some such dribble. In actual fact; most are lucky to be 15 years old. I have even seen an Asian reproduction Rocking Horse advertised on a general auction site as “Elizabethan”.
1) “Velocipedes” (Tricycle horses)
These are actually made in Asia with an “Antiqued” finish and sold through trading houses as 1800’s out of Countries like Germany to give them some credibility. If a Velocipede were genuine, then you would not find it on general auction sites and would be commanding many thousands of dollars.
The genuine German and French ones were often fur covered and are extremely rare now days; it is extremely unlikely that we would find one here in Australia; if there were one; the owner/collector would not part with it; nor would they put it on a general auction site.
2) Bow Rockers
Most of these are Balinese; once again “Antiqued”.
3) Pull along/Platform Horses
Same as above but made in the Philippines.
4) Swing Rockers
Same again; but Balinese.
5) Hide Covered
It is unlikely these are either “Victorian”, “Antique” or even “Vintage”; put simply, they are most likely 1980’s or younger; in fact; they can still be purchased new here is Australia by Equine Manufacturing.
There were some old English Hide Covered horses made; as was some early Australian ones made as early as 1948; but it is highly unlikely these will have survived due to shrinking and hardening of the hide etc.
It is important to note here that it isn’t the manufacturer that is misrepresenting these horses; it is the sellers.
6) Plastic Horses
Well, actually polyethylene.
In Australia, these were made by Australian Rocking Horse Mfg., Lindsay’s and some by Cyclops.
They certainly are not “Antique” or even “Vintage” since they were only made from 1974.
Those made by Australian Rocking Horse Mfg had a cast made from a late model Roebuck and went into production after the Roebuck factory closed. Some of these were sold to Lindsay’s as their Deluxe model.
The advantage of polyethylene horses is they are lightweight, the disadvantage is they are nowhere as strong as timber and paint does not stick to it long term. Therefore when people paint them up it all tends to come off again and their hard work was in vein.
The only real way is to clean them with Sugar Soap, heat the areas in which you wish to paint and whilst the plastic is hot, spray with acrylic paint so it is trapped in the pores when the plastic cools.
Apparently now days bumper bar paint will stick, though I haven’t personally tried it.
There are two excellent high quality reference books which are considered by those in the Rocking Horse trade as the encyclopedia of Rocking Horses; they are highly recommended and fascinating reading:
THE ROCKING HORSE, A history of moving toy horses by Patricia Mullins.
This covers most major Rocking Horses from many countries and gives an excellent insight to the various Rocking Horse styles that have evolved around the world.
A KISS OF ROCKING HORSES, A Directory of British Rocking Horse Makers pre 1950 by David Kiss.
This book focuses in on the history of the British Rocking Horses, the various trading names, dates and addresses etc; if you need to find identify some minute detail of a certain British Rocking Horse, then this book will most likely have the answer.
In short; Caveat Emptor (Let the buyer beware).
If a buy seems too good to be true; then it probably is.
If you are not sure about the legitimacy of a Rocking Horse; contact a reputable Rocking Horse Restorer; NOT and Antique Shop or Dealer.
Tip; it is unlikely you will find an “Antique” or “Victorian” Rocking Horse for sale on general auction sites…Sorry to disillusion you; that bargain most likely isn’t.